Criticism of the Hadith of Hadhrat Umme Hani Part - 2

That <i>Hadhrat Umme Hani (May Allah be well pleased with her) </i>was not a Muslim does not affect the authenticity of the journey, as in Makkah the command to break all relations with the non-Muslims and it is not mentioned anywhere about <i>Hadhrat Umme Hani (May Allah be well pleased with her)</i> that she had committed any form of Shirk.&nbsp;&nbsp;The<b> Holy Prophet (Sallallahu alaihi wa sallam)</b> would go to her house to turn her to Islam and it is because of the blessings of these visits that she turned a Muslim.<br /> <br /> In the narration of <span style="color: #993300">Hadith</span>, every criticism is not to be accepted and every Dhaif (weakly-authenticated) Hadith is not unworthy of consideration.&nbsp;&nbsp;The Hadith of <i>Hadhrat Umme Hani (May Allah be well pleased with her)</i> is present in Mojam Kabeer of Imam Tabarani.<br /> <br /> The interpreters of Sahih Bukhari, the <i>Imams Hadhrat Badruddin Aini Hanafi </i>and <i>Hadhrat Ibn Hajr Asqalani (May Allah shower His Mercy on them) </i>would not have reconciled this Hadith with others if this Hadith was not to be considered.&nbsp;&nbsp;They would have simply said that this Hadith is Dhaif.&nbsp;&nbsp;The word and opinion of these Imams of Hadith carries much weight.<br />